Controversy Surrounding Gay Marriage The Controversy Surrounding Gay Marriage The debate of gay marriage is very complex, due to the many different feelings people express on the topic. One opinion is that gay marriage should be legalized nationally. Others feel that gay marriage should not be legalized but civil unions should be granted to homosexuals so they have an alternative that allows gays and lesbians to receive something that compares to the same rights as marriage. On the other hand there is a large group that believes neither gay marriage nor civil unions should be offered to gay and lesbian couples and that any legal union should be available to heterosexual couples only.
One article has distinguished between act and rule utilitarianism by referring to them as "extreme" and "restricted" utilitarianism. This article claims that the extreme or act version of utilitarianism will use the rules of morality as rules of thumb only.
Those rules can be changed at any time in the interest of the greatest good or greatest happiness. This article claims that act utilitarianism is superior to rule utilitarianism because the act utilitarian recognizes the principle of utility as overriding.
The act utilitarian recognizes that even though it is not possible in every instance to be sure that the course of action is not in favor of the one who acts, and that it may not be the case in every instance that we have time to weigh the action at hand.
It seems odd to claim that if we did have time, if we were sure that our actions were not in favor of ourselves, and that we were sure that the action against a rule was the right one, that we should not perform an action that does not conform to a rule.
Overall, this article claims that to act on a rule when we have had the chance to weigh the benefits, is to treat the rule superstitiously.
We would be treating it superstitiously because we are acting as if it was an object of worship. However, another article claims that it cannot be correct to choose act utilitarianism over rule utilitarianism because it would lead to the destruction of important social relationships, such as the family.
This leads to the differences between instrumental relationships, and diffuse relationship. There are some human relationships that would collapse if the act utilitarian principle were used as the principle of action. An example is presented about a husband and wife who discuss whether it would be to the husband's greatest benefit to leave his wife if she was ill and had little chance of regaining her health.
Although this is a very insensitive example, it is concluded that a consequences of weighing the benefits is that it destroys the family, which is not of little importance or instrumental value to many people.
This means that a diffuse relationship is one that should be supported, so that the family is not considered to be an instrumental relationship. An example of an instrumental relationship would be in a business or social setting in which certain people are given tasks that they must complete, but they cannot and should not expect support outside of that area.
This article concluded that for the most desirable standards to be observed, men must have confidence in each other's behavior.The Controversy Surrounding Gay Marriage The debate of gay marriage is very complex, due to the many different feelings people express on the topic.
Same Sex Marriage Essay Examples. total results. An Introduction to the Importance of the Legalization of Same Sex Marriage in the United States. 2, words. The Controversy Surrounding Gay Marriage.
1, words. 3 pages. Same Sex Marriages Should Be . Gay Marriage Essay Sample.
Abstract The paper examines the parallel development of marriage and gay issues converging on contentious controversy surrounding gay marriage. The author contends that marriage and gay issues are two different things with different histories though converging on the question of human relationships, specifically.
Jan 09, · The Controversy of Gay Parenting Essay Words | 4 Pages The Controversy of Gay Parenting Gay parenting is an issue that affects a great number of people worldwide.
The tools you need to write a quality essay or term paper; Saved Essays. You Have Not Saved Any Essays. Topics in this paper.
There is now controversy surrounding the issue of legally recognizing gay marriages and giving the benefits of marriage such as joint tax returns, and benefits for spouses. Banning gay marriage would mean.
Aug 25, · cultural development in America in the last twenty-five years has definitely been the legalization of gay marriage. Few other issues in public policy have resulted in such a dramatic shift in public opinion as the controversy same-sex marriage and the rights that come along with the institute of marriage.